Electric Cars

729 readers

1 users here now

Discussion of EVs and the technology around them

founded 2 years ago

MODERATORS

[email protected]

Buying an EV? Don't Waste Your Money on That Sporty AWD Model (www.gearpatrol.com)

submitted 2 years ago by [email protected] to c/[email protected]

5 comments fedilink hide all child comments

Thoughts? I live in a wintery biome so having awd gives me a bit of peace of mind

top 5 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old

[–] [email protected] 1 points 2 years ago (1 children)

I've owned several FWD EVs in what I'd consider the wintery parts of BC (snowfall of 8+ meters anually) and the amount of times I got stuck as a result of not having AWD can be counted on one hand. Good driving habits and high-end winter tires are much, much more important than having AWD or not.

That said, the times I did get stuck were mostly a bit annoying if not embarassing (due to holding up traffic). Only once (while climbing a steep hill) did it actually get a bit sketchy due to backsliding, but that happened to every vehicle that had to come to a stop on that hill.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 2 years ago

I'll take good tires over AWD any day in a Saskatchewan winter. It's interesting how influenced people have become to essentially the opposite of safety measures. AWD doesn't help you stop, and taller bigger vehicles aren't safer, they're much more likely to roll.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 2 years ago* (last edited 2 years ago)

I've driven an EV for five years and made a 50km daily one way commute over rural, highway and city streets for 15 years. I live in Canada and we get snow , freezing rain and more weather. In my experience good driving habits > AWD all day everyday.

Pay attention to the road conditions, don't drive faster than the weather will allow, get winter tires, keep your brakes maintained, drive a safe speed even when others are impatient, leave room to stop, if the weather is bad enough don't leave at all, if you must leave plan to leave early enough that you aren't tempted to make bad driving decisions such as speeding. This isn't rocket science, but over the last 15 years and 540,000 km I have seen several impatient people pass me in the winter weather just to end up seeing them again in the ditch within 10 minutes. That includes 1 4x4 truck, 1 AWD SUV and at least 2 sedans.

The Bros in the truck all had to climb out the passenger side since it landed on its drivers side, the lady in the SUV was stuck down in the gutter and told me not to worry, she'd call a tow, and in the case of one sedan I ended up driving this small family home, car seat and all. Will AWD help you get yourself out of a slick parking spot, or start up at a red light? Sure, maybe, it depends. But it isn't really going to help with much else and doesn't come close to just learning to drive to the conditions.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 2 years ago (1 children)

I think I agree with you. The author mentions AWD in snow as a minor passing thing in a way you can tell they haven't lived somewhere with it.

But that said I haven't driven an EV and I'd be worried about the extra direct torque they can provide making starting on ice or snowpack more difficult and dangerous.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 2 years ago* (last edited 2 years ago)

Depends where you live with lots of snow. If you're not emergency personnel and you live in a major metropolitan area with good salting and plowing? You absolutely do not need AWD. If you're like in the GTA or the Chicago sprawl you'll be fine - make sure to pick up your groceries the day before the blizzard. Any day where the roads are bad-enough to need an all-terrain vehicle, everything will be closed anyways. The only urban places I'd be tempted by AWD would be the Prairies Provinces, where they sometimes get snow below -10C (usually it's bone dry here in Ontario when it gets below -10C) and salt can't melt that so they just dump in some grit and hope. At least it's pretty flat there.

However, if you live rural? Absolutely. My in-laws live in a hilly rural area and I've tried visiting them in an FWD minivan in the winter. Do not recommend.