rdp over tailscale
this post was submitted on 28 Jul 2024
59 points (98.4% liked)
Asklemmy
43746 readers
1310 users here now
A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
Search asklemmy π
If your post meets the following criteria, it's welcome here!
- Open-ended question
- Not offensive: at this point, we do not have the bandwidth to moderate overtly political discussions. Assume best intent and be excellent to each other.
- Not regarding using or support for Lemmy: context, see the list of support communities and tools for finding communities below
- Not ad nauseam inducing: please make sure it is a question that would be new to most members
- An actual topic of discussion
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
- Lemmyverse: community search
- sub.rehab: maps old subreddits to fediverse options, marks official as such
- [email protected]: a community for finding communities
~Icon~ ~by~ ~@Double_[email protected]~
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
RustDesk is good and open source too
Parsec if you're using it for windows
I switched over to anydesk when TeamViewer started enshitifying itself, haven't looked back it works great on all my devices, even my phone (as in I can control my PC from my phone I use it a ton)
Setup is super easy, just make sure to set up proper passwords for it, specially if you use public wifi
AnyDesk has started enshitifying too but it's still better than TeamViewer.
I remeber it used to be free for personal use, but it seems it's paid plan only?
I use it for free in android Linux and windows sooo no, I'm not sure we're you're getting that info from
I went to https://anydesk.com/en and got confused. I remeber (or maybe I just say so myself) years and years ago it stated obviously it's free for personal use. Now it's just generic site with links to download and not much info and obviously aimed at companies and their $$.
You can literally just download and use it, do you expect a free software not to have some sort of paid option in it's site? All the paid stuff is for business use, if you're just using it for yourself they don't ask for payment info nor do they bother you to pay at any moment
It's understandable they have paid version. It was always there. But the wording around was dayn and night different and that's what confused me. I needed "teamviewer alternative" last month, went there confident I have a solution, but after a moment of looking at the new-to-me site I was honestly not sure whether I can use it or not. More reading didn't really help in this regard, so I went with RustDesk instead. It did the job I needed and ia open source on top of it.
Maybe the Windows clients are paid now? But I use it currently for free on many Linux boxes. I haven't logged into one of the Windows boxes like my mother's office computer to fix something in a while.
And it also supports port forwarding. Android client included.
I have had nothing but great experience from Parsec. It's gaming intended, but works perfectly for simple remote desktop use as well. Very low latency. Can start when windows boots, so you can even sign in remotely if you need to restart. Free
VNC is the kind of the baseline remote desktop that works on pretty much any operating system. You can start there & then decide if you need specific features that the others have.
You didn't mention your own OS but it too probably already has support for its own remote desktop solution.
Moonlight and sunshine. Best desktop streaming experience
I set this up initially for gaming, but slowly am ending up using it more for remote than gaming...
If yoy need rdp, ssh, and vnc, i really like apache guacamole. If you want remote assistance software, i like rust desk.
TeamViewer, not a fan of the new interface, but it functions well.
I use it to help multiple family members.
I like Tailscale and regular RDP.
Rust desk
+1
FOSS or freeware?
Well the first thing it says on their website is βthe open source alternative to teamviewerβ
This. I left TeamViewer after they flagged me as commercial. I've been using them for my home computers and 3d printers for ever. Now I do rust desk
They flagged me too, but i just contacted them and said I'm not. Got unflagged pretty fast.
I only use it to support family members though
RustDesk says that it's compatible with Windows. Is RDP better still?
Depends on use case. If your trying to remoting to a friends PC to help them do something. Rustdesk.
If your remoting to your own PC. Say connecting to a windows machine at home from your work computer. RDP.
Also as others have mentioned. Best to use RDP through something like tailscale or zerotier. So you don't have to open a port for it.
Thank you!
RDP is kind of limited because it's a virtual session. It's useful if you only need to do stuff while you're actively connected but you can't, for example, remote in and start an app or process going and then disconnect and have that app continue. When you d/c your profile is essentially logged out. Your activity also can't be viewed by a user on the remote system, if you needed to collaborate or assist somehow.
UltraVNC has worked ok for me for windows systems. It has some of that open-source clunk to the UI, but is pretty straight forward and does what I need.
What? This just isn't true? I RDP into work all time and it picks up my user session with all open apps from the last time I was physically at the machine. Then next time I'm at the machine, it picks up the session from last time I remoted in. In other words, as long as you always use the same account, it's always the same session.
Your activity also can't be viewed by a user on the remote system
You are right this, but this is actually a benefit in my opinion. The last thing I want is for someone to turn on my monitor and see everything I'm doing. I like that it's a private session of sorts.
Also RDP is better at adapting resolutions (I want my session to use my local monitors' resolution, not the remote one) and forwarding system key shortcuts than any other remote solution I've used.
RDP is kind of limited
Itβs useful if you only need to do stuff while youβre actively connected but you canβt, for example, remote in and start an app or process going and then disconnect and have that app continue.
Sure you can, I do this all the time on the work RDP server. Maybe you need to tweak your group policy so it doesn't kick you out right away.
When you d/c your profile is essentially logged out.
Nope, depends on what group policy you configured. If you've never configured that before as a starter launch gpedit.msc (with admin privileges) and head to Administrative Templates / Windows Components / Remote Desktop Services / Remote Desktop Session Host / Session Time Limits. The other settings in there are also useful for other things you may want to configure.
Your activity also canβt be viewed by a user on the remote system, if you needed to collaborate or assist somehow.
Yes this is true, the only way to do that is to have admin privileges on the host and then take over that user session. But of course that's not collaboration, that's just you taking a user's current session without them being able to see what you're doing.
On Windows the official way to do that is via Quick Assist (on Windows 10, not sure if it got renamed on Windows 11), it's sort of a shared RDP session where both the user and the remote user can share the same session. I've never needed to use it myself - with the work system users are pretty content with just having me "fix" whatever they needed without them watching, they usually don't care how to fix the problem themselves LOL.
What do you mean by logged out if you disconnect? I disconnect and leave sessions logged in all the time.
I use TeamViewer for occasional IT support and it does it fine.