I really love the way the expansive HBO budget amplifies the comedic stakes. For example, we know that they really will pay for some pretty wild stuff, such as physically exactingly recreating a section of an airport with functional restaurants inside. That adds a funny sort of credibility to little gags like the "get the dog sniffing air from the right city" bit, which they obviously didn't really do and only needs to be communicated through a couple of quick insert shots of a truck and a guy with a hose, but your brain at least briefly accepts in a "sure, why not" way because of the context
this post was submitted on 05 May 2025
49 points (100.0% liked)
Movies & TV
23307 readers
311 users here now
Rules for Movies & TV Discussion
-
Any discussion of Disney properties should contain a (cw: imperialism) tag. If your post isn't tagged appropriately it will be removed.
-
Anti-Bong Joon-ho trolling will result in an immediate ban from c/movies and submitted to the site administrators for review.
-
On Star Trek Sunday only posts discussing how we might achieve space communism are permitted. Non-Star Trek related content will be removed and you will be temporarily banned until the following Sunday.
Here's a list of tons of leftist movies.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
i tried watching season 1. it's probably a very good show but it makes me far too uncomfortable to sit through
When he started shaving his teats, I said aloud "what is he doing!" But then it all came together.
Hell yeah and it's been amazing. Amy Lee has posted that she thinks he's a genius and also it turns out Captain Sully is very much still alive and really confused. The fact that he's still alive and Nathan did all this instead of just talking to the guy is pretty amazing.
The fact that he’s still alive and Nathan did all this instead of just talking to the guy is pretty amazing.
That's what I really want to know. Did he reach out to Sullenberger at any point? I feel like it would be REALLY in his style to make this entire episode, then bring Sullenberger in to watch the tape and give feedback/commentary on Nathan recreating his own life.
I'm wondering if Sullenberger just declined to be involved or if they truly never contacted him before it aired. That'd be absolutely wild if the first time Sullenberger found out about this was 2 nights ago when it aired.
I doubt they'll bring him on, they don't usually continue this kind of bit beyond its episode.
I agree. I think if Sullenberger had agreed to be on it would have been at the end of episode 3. I'm just wondering if they tried to get him and he declined, if they asked his permission at all, or if Sullenberger was totally in the dark about the whole thing until it aired.
did all this instead of just talking
this is like the premise of the show since season 1. it all started with a guy who couldnt just talk to his friend
nathan is the best thing to come out of this fake ass country in many years. give him 20 seasons
The fake ass country in this case is Canada
From what I understand he got pretty good grades too
Nathan for You as a concept began as a This Hour Has 22 Minutes sketch. We gave the world Trailer Park Boys, the genesis of whatever Nathan Fielder is AND The Lighthouse. Maritimes rule!
The Lighthouse is so good. So are the rest of those. And dont forget picnicface!
But Nathan is from the west coast, right?
He is but This Hour is filmed in halifax so he was on the east coast when the Nathan for You concept was born. The west coast also ears their garlic fingers with fucking marinara.
I absolutely love how Nathan keeps blurring the lines between how the audience feels they are supposed to parse the narrative and how he is explicitly communicating it. The way he lampshades stuff while actively letting the audience in on the purpose of the lampshading (i.e. the clown stuck under the car bit from S2S1) is so genius because it makes you keep guessing and trying to outsmart him. The actor acknowledging the war room framing in the Paramount conversation was another example.
He's playing with us on so many levels that it's just unreal.
YES. what an experience. so far my favorite part is the
spoiler
canadian idol episode. The paramount nazi bit was so fucking funny, and seeing Nathan deliver that No at the end was the perfect ending
And I recently started playing FlightGear (open source flight sim). So it's really adding to the current obsession
That episode was so wild. I was trying to explain it to my wife and she was like, "so he lied to these people to get them to audition?" At first I was about to agree, but like, he didn't lie? His only promise was that the winner would get to perform a public domain song on national television on an exact recreation of the Houston airport. And, like, he can deliver that quite easily at this point. He just created an entire reality TV show for a bit on a single episode.
The whole bit about how he is lying and manipulating people is best explored in the Rehearsal's first season. The subtext is that people put on a thin performance on stage, and the situations he is "voluntarily" placing them in are very questionable when you consider the coercive power of a camera crew. There's an inherent mismatch between reality and reality TV. So how is any reality TV ethical? The more real it gets, the more exploitative! You can't capture real emotion and real stakes, especially when it involves children or people in trouble, without seriously compromising ethics.
Maybe the whole point is encapsulated in the interaction in that episode where he is talking with the two ladies, and they ask if there is a prize and he basically just tells them point blank that the whole thing is a sham but they still go along with it. It's because people have to go along with it, you have a camera pointed at their face and you already made them jump through a bunch of hoops to get to that point.
I enjoy it when the subjects/actors have the ability to be in on the bit. The kid in s1 was pretty fucked up. That kid genuinely believed Nathan had become his new dad. I felt so bad for him.
spoiler
I'm looking forward to seeing the performance with the backing band
I haven't watched episode 3 yet. the paramount bit from episode 2 was absolutely wild though
Episode 3 is PACKED. We're talking adult babies dog clones, diabetic attack reactments, masturbating in a plane, Cheryl Crow AND Evanescence
holy fuck you weren't kidding. Nathan Fielder is a fucking genius.
I was waiting for the whole season to air, but should I just start anyway?
I would. Each episode is really a lot to take in, I'm glad I've got a week between each.
Just saw it. Season 2 keeps getting better and better.
I have Rehearsal S1 downloaded and I'm pretty sure it was on Hexbear's recommendation...working through a few other shows right now, but I'll pop it in the queue
Season 1 is also amazing. There really is nothing even somewhat like it
This contest is over, give Nathan Fielder the ten thousand dollars!
Thanks for reminding me its out! Nathan is amazing lol
I really liked s1, and yall are just stoking the embers of motivation to watch s2
It's really something else
S2 blows S1 out of the sky.
I was really skeptical after s1. I LOVED it, but that final episode when the kid genuinely thought Nathan was his dad and couldn't separate the fiction from the reality, it really fucked me up. I'm just glad kids aren't involved this season so far.
Absolutely amazing use of HBO money.
I'm trying to explain the premise to people I know but I'm doing a terrible job at it and no one is giving it a chance.
I've tried the same and even describing a single episode is just....not doable
i love the show but i have no idea how to explain to people who have never seen the show (or any nathan fielder project) how its so good and worth watching
It's amazing. I assume HBO is just letting him do whatever he wants. I don't even know how you'd pitch episode 3 to a network exec.
Season 1 was good too, but covid definitely fucked up their plans.
I am. It's great and I too have had no one follow up that they've watched. It's really good so far
it's some of the most incredible television i've ever seen and I literally can't get anyone i know to watch it lmao