this post was submitted on 10 Jul 2025
1 points (100.0% liked)
electoralism
22150 readers
1 users here now
Welcome to c/electoralism! politics isn't just about voting or running for office, but this community is.
Please read the Chapo Code of Conduct and remember...we're all comrades here.
Shitposting in other comms please!
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
FD, outside of his analysis of black culture and leftist relations to black folk, is often weak and still pretty lib-coded. A decent part of that I think is lived experience over theoretical comprehension, e.g., my complaints in my other comment. Though it has been honestly a while since I've engaged with this type of YouTube content, so maybe I am misremembering. I found the video very good as a primer for white baby leftists on being careful in engaging with black people and mistakes to avoid. But his explanations were fairly lacking, but frankly, anyone who needs this message probably isn't reading theory, notably black liberation theory, to the point of even properly engaging in the explanation, and obviously doesn't have the lived experience to combat it.
I didn't find his address of bernie to be particularly problematic, frankly, FD does attack revolutionary socialists, but in addressing electoralists, I think him drawing the distinction in any capacity, would cause the exact tuning out and lecturing he was talking about (further than has already happened in the comments of that vid lol). If we're talking about tactics, I think leaving that unmentioned in a video this short with the purpose it serves is correct, considering the tendencies of the people he's trying to address.
Though, the cynic in me thinks the primary effectiveness will derive from it hitting lib white guilt more than anything else. I don't think this video was bad for what it was intended to be, but anyone who has engaged in the L of ML shouldn't really need this video to begin with.
yes i should say i think of his vids of "good vs bad" through my mindset as a "decolonial ML sympathizer" lol. his bad vids are all mostly b side channel stuff like this where he wades into more explicit political stuff that i think exposes his lack of serious study into these areas. i should also say I hold him to a higher standard as someone who regularly platforms much more radical people than himself if that makes any sense.
to be more specific i wish he would connect bernie's weakness in addressing the concerns of black people to his total lack of concern for the colonial subjects outside of the US' borders, possible i missed this (im drunk rn i will admit). i think i get where you're coming from as far as the focus on electoralists being necessary for the vid, but i still think there is room to make it more clear without dipping into that territory of doing that lecturing? idk, something like "even many of you more 'principled' revolutionary socialists ignore this"? i am not black so as far as exact wording and what not i dont want to make any firm claims lol
i guess my wish is that he will utilize his incredible ability to hit white lib guilt buttons and gently nudge them in a more revolutionary, scientific socialist way if that makes sense.
I love analysis while drunk, so I relate. And no, you didn't miss it. I think a part of it is him having the role of the Black Lorax. It's something him and other cornbreadtubers (the name is ironic) riff on about him but I think he does take with some degree of seriousness and frankly a lot of "leftists" that haven't found some sort of ideological coherence still heavily fuck with bernie. They'd click off faster than a gamer says a slur if he called Bernie an imperialist dog. Hell, we're still catching shit for many leftists not voting for Kamala out of principle.
Besides, the same blind spot Bernie has, a lot of these leftists have frankly. Bernie's fairly blatant imperialism works because of the class essentialism that is fairly prevalent in the Western left. Bernie does it as an imperial dog, but I think the reflection seen would lead to defensiveness and reactionary tendencies. JD is still actively playing the same role he was when I first found him. He's a baby's guide to The Black Question, and I think his idea is that by platforming others, he can give them the opportunity to pull a Luxembourg. I do agree he could lean a little further into the left regarding that, though, as he often has throwaway comments for other, much further left ideas in a way that pokes fun as well as generates interest. It likely is part of his blind spot, regardless of the tactical intent, though.
think we largely agree here, hopefully final clarification of myself lol but i dont think FD is harmful to the left like i think typical breadtubers are, for instance iirc he has more than one vid in which he makes fun of people that use the word "tankie" which many other people on "breadtube" would never dare to do. when i want him to connect bernie's (rhetorical) failings towards his failings towards externally colonized people i dont want him to call him Bernie $$ander$$ (as funny as that would be) or anything like that, dont even have to use any mean words like imperialism, just put something in the vid to hint at the connection idk if that makes sense
btw cornbreadtube is one of my favorite yet wasted concepts on yt, ik it was never serious but tweaking breadtubes nose in how white and rich they are was an incredible idea that never really fully came to fruition like i would have liked lol