this post was submitted on 25 Jun 2025
199 points (99.5% liked)
United States | News & Politics
3034 readers
1077 users here now
Welcome to [email protected], where you can share and converse about the different things happening all over/about the United States.
If you’re interested in participating, please subscribe.
Rules
Be respectful and civil. No racism/bigotry/hateful speech.
Post anything related to the United States.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
It was the culmination of a whole series of increasingly-disastrous court decisions.
Turns out, when you allow any one person to have massive amounts of power (money in the case of capitalism), they will do everything possible to seize more power.
You can also consider the fact that elitism was a massive part of the founding of the US, which is why we have situations like the Senate where land votes more than people, the Electoral College which does the same thing, not banning slavery from day 1 which we're still seeing the effects of to this day, not having any method for federal direct ballot initiatives, etc.
The issue is capitalism itself, as individuals are still allowed to hold power over other people one way or the other.
To be fair, (a) at the time, that was considered to be an improvement over an upper legislative chamber made out of actual hereditary aristocracy, and (b) the US was designed to be a confederation of sovereign individual States, more closely resembling how the EU works today.
(I wonder how many folks here who are sharply critical of how 'undemocratic' the US Senate is would get mad at me if I, in turn, advocated for abolishing the European Commission and Council of Ministers, so that Germany could be even more dominant over Greece etc. than it already is.)
a) Improvement doesn't necessailly mean good or effective in the long term.
b) The design ceases to matter when the execution doesn't match. Actions speak louder than words. We have also given the federal executive branch much more power than necessary, and they have continuously ceased more power, whether that be through intelligence agencies acting extrajudicially and unconstitutionally (NSA, CIA, FBI, etc.), waging war on drugs (and therefore, the American people) and militarizing the police, the president having immunity for all crimes that are "official acts", etc.
There is also the undemocratic Supreme Court, who with Marbury v Madison, gave themselves the ability to essentially unilaterally enact laws.
I can't comment on EU politics because I don't know much about it.