this post was submitted on 27 Jun 2024
0 points (NaN% liked)
Україна | Ukraine 🇺🇦
1464 readers
1 users here now
Welcome to Ukraine!
Ласкаво просимо в Україну!
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
You can not say these things do not have "the connotations or baggage" (how dismissive) that "westerners attach to it." The N word is an English word with one use, dehumanizing people of African ancestry. Blackface and Sambo imagery are also borne of white supremacist ideals and dehumanizing Africans. That is specifically where this stuff comes from. There is no alternative interpretation. You could maybe say someone is ignorant of the history of the N word, but if you are not racist garbage, the intent of blackface and Sambo imagery is very clear without needing a history lesson. Acting as an apologist for racists is functionally the same as being racist. I'm sure you've heard the expression about having dinner with 9 Nazis. 10 Nazis are having dinner.
American culture is interwoven with the black slavery history, most of the rest of the world is not. So no, they don't have that baggage when it comes to black face or the like. Like you don't understand the Indian caste system, for example.
Making them out as racists is stupid if you stop to think about it and not just give kneejerk reactions. Not everyone is as obsessed with race like Americans.
Because the rest of the world had nothing to do with black people ending up in the Americas and gained nothing from the whole ordeal
How do you know what I understand about the Indian caste system? Racist caricatures are racist caricatures, even if that culture finds racism to be acceptable. You clowns really love to act like embracing racism is somehow enlightened, goddamn.
I'm very much reading someone with a very narrow world view lecturing me without making any real effort to understand what im saying.
You're imposing your morals and values as well as any colonizer or ethnocentrist I've ever known!
Not tolerating racism is a narrow world view? You aren't hiding your power level very well.
What a load of shit. One of the ways that we can communicate across languages and cultures is via imagery. Blackface and Sambo imagery isn't limited by USA hegemony. It's pretty clear the meaning. You didn't address that at all.
Exactly, thank you. Gotta love these "enlightened" racists.
Yes they can in fact say this. You do realize english is not the only language that exists or ever existed right ? Or that northern american culture is not hegemonic (yet) ?
Niger/nigra/nigrum is a latin word that simply means black or dark without all the prejudice attached to it in english, and believe it or not, variations of that root word still exist in a shitload of european languages and dialects to signify the exact same thing : a color.
To claim as you do that the denigrative usage of the word is the only understanding some farmer from the depths of the Urals should have is frankly preposterous.
What's preposterous is the number of people who get upset, make excuses, and try and throw it back when I call out racism. Before I paste what I said in another comment, I'd like to point out that I specifically said that some non native English speakers may be ignorant of the history of the n word. Anyway:
While I understand the similarity with the latin languages, as it shares that origin, it is its own word. The actual word is being used, not words that sound alike, as it was exported by colonial powers.
I am only going to be expanding on your discussion of the N-word specifically, and not the larger discussion. While the N-word is abominable in English, because the word for black in a lot of languages came from the Latin word "nigreos", a lot of languages have words that sound like the N-word but are not. The word just means the color black. That's just the etymology of the Latin word. If you have personal experience living in those areas then I'll definitely add more weight to your comment, because I haven't.
While I understand the similarity with the latin languages, as it shares that origin, it is its own word. The actual word is being used, not words that sound alike, as it was exported by colonial powers. I don't have to have lived there to be aware of its use. Hell, anyone that read the post is now aware, there wasn't any confusion as to what was stated in the peace corps document.
Apparently there is because the post clearly states that there is a possibility a volunteer might hear that word but it not be intentionally racist. You're completely ignoring that half the message is 'evaluate and determine if it is ignorance or racism'.
You're completely ignoring what I'm actually saying to keep pushing your own narrative. I specifically stated they may be ignorant of the origin of the n word, but you know that. That's why you and these other racists keep harping on that and not addressing the issue of racist depictions. Ya'll are so obvious, I could almost laugh.
Because the issue isn't racist depictions. It's a lack of education and a focus on intolerance instead of actually employing the sympathy you are demanding. Nobody is arguing the word or imagery is fundamentally racist in origin. We're saying they honestly don't know about that so need education. That's the context you are ignoring to go on your black knight crusade.
You are the exact opposite of what the Peace Corps is asking their members to be. Hear the offensive word and you go on a rage fueled violent rant about how racist they are being instead of taking a deep breathe, looking at the situation and realizing they only use the word because it is the only one they know. Simply taking the time to inform them of how hurtful the word/imagery is without being a salty bitch about it is how fences are mended.
Again, you're the one focusing on the word and continuing to outright ignore the comment about racist depictions. Again, ya'll are very obvious, especially "black knight." Ya'll are racist Trash and full of shit to boot.
Thank you for proving my point
Your point that you keep talking about the n word and that isn't even what the focus was? Really what is your point? You're a racist who finds racism acceptable and is deeply offended that anyone would point out that being racist makes you a shitty person? That your point?