this post was submitted on 31 Jan 2024
314 points (98.2% liked)
[Outdated, please look at pinned post] Casual Conversation
6593 readers
1 users here now
Share a story, ask a question, or start a conversation about (almost) anything you desire. Maybe you'll make some friends in the process.
RULES
- Be respectful: no harassment, hate speech, bigotry, and/or trolling
- Encourage conversation in your post
- Avoid controversial topics such as politics or societal debates
- Keep it clean and SFW: No illegal content or anything gross and inappropriate
- No solicitation such as ads, promotional content, spam, surveys etc.
- Respect privacy: Don’t ask for or share any personal information
Related discussion-focused communities
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I believe most of us here block as many ads as possible by any means possible. I so rarely see ads that every once in while when I do (on other peoples devices) I'm shocked and disgusted.
https://github.com/pi-hole/pi-hole
https://ublockorigin.com/
https://brave.com/
Is enough for me. If I watch YouTube on mobile it's in Brave browser as that block the ads on iOS.
If I watch YouTube on my TV it's in https://smarttubeapp.github.io/ which also blocks ads.
You don't have to live like that and I feel sorry for all the people that do.
All that being said I know what you mean, even the content itself is now saturated with ads, i.e. a word about our sponsor for five minutes at the start of any video...
How do you actually load the smart tube app on your TV? I have a chromecast btw.
EDIT: Just figured it out. Involves installing the Downloader app on my chromecast from the Google Play Store, then within the Downloader app I downloaded and installed the Smart Tube apk file from GitHub (after enabling Developer Mode in chromecast settings first).
Tested it on a gamer content creator channel and it skipped the sponsor segment at the very beginning. I’m in!
I have a FireTV stick so I had to use Downloader to get the APK and install it.
Big budget movies nowadays tend to be riddled with Product Placement so not even all that you're doing will save you from Ads. Product Placement Ads are just generally more subtle than those in dedicated Ad Spaces (though the latest Aquaman was not at all subtle in their in-movie add for a certain beer brand: it kind left you with a bitter taste in your mouth and not in a good way).
I’m sure you know about Brave being called out here lately so I just want to give you some iOS alternatives so you can stop using Brave (if you care enough, of course)
AdGuard (I paid for the lifetime, $12 I think) and it works great. Just like having uBlock on Firefox, but in safari so I still get all the integration that safari offers on your iOS device.
Dark reader is on the App Store.
When it comes to YouTube, I sideload a YouTube app with all the essentials installed using Sideloadly.
The rest is up to you.
If you are looking for a good YouTube client on iOS, you don't even have to get into sideloading. Check out Yattee with this guide.
Unfortunately, AdGuard for iOS does not block ads in Safari as promised, at least not with the free tier (I double checked the instructions and toggled on all AdGuard related features in Settings). ~~Comparing it to uBlock in Firefox is laughable.~~
For example, I searched for lasagna recipes, still saw ads in search results on DDG. Clicked a link to allrecipes.com, and bam—multiple banner ads embedded in the page before I can even read the actual recipe, plus another one docked to the bottom of my screen. Fail.
EDIT: Clarified that I’m referring to the free tier of Ad Guard, which I think is fair to say represents most users’ experience with it.
would you mind sharing the exact url?
I do know that you need to manually update the blocklist through the AdGuard app.
Comparing it to uBlock on Firefox is laughable how? You do know that there is a way to add or remove any blocklist you want in the app. Now, this is only with the pro or paid version which is one of the reasons other than blocking ads as stated that I decided to spend my money on it.
World’s Best Lasaga - scroll down past the image carousel and the little box that shows prep time, cook time, and servings. Under the prep time box, before the orange “Jump to Recipe” button, there’s an ad.
Thank you for following through with the url!
I was able to slowly scroll down all the way to the very bottom of the page and saw no ads at all.
I also need to let you know that I use their DNS protection which you might not have ticked in the settings. I wish I could help you, but I think if you dig more into the app, you’ll see more options that will allow you to block just like I have. :/
That looks how I’d expect it with just the basic free protection. Based on the description of that feature in Ad Guard (emphasis mine):
Alas, I’m not ready to spring for the premium tier, at least not yet (but never say never).
Thanks for sharing what it could look like, though.
I see what you’re saying. I instantly went for the trial because I saw how cheap the lifetime was and if it worked well enough, they could have that $12.
I apologize for misleading you. The app does work as intended for me.
I do understand about not springing for premium! I loathe ads so much that I’ll pay for something to get them out of my face. 😅
I appreciate the well thought out and articulated response.
The thing is it's not like I'm blindly using Brave; I've tried to dig into these things with Brave which users have brought up, the biggest complaints usually being "forced" cryptostuff (I had mine on first, and now off...), affiliate links and Brendan Eich being an anti lgbt asshole, etc. Then I went down the same hole with Mozilla; their asshole execs laying off people and then giving themselves bonuses, making deals with Google, etc.
Richard Stallmans an asshole too, should I stop using GNU? The world is a fucked up place and people are the most fucked up of all and pitting my morals against pragmatism sometimes only gets me so and so far.
I'd love to get behind some sort of new open-source alternative; I'm hoping we get a viable new thing ASAP, waiting for someone to pull a Linus and create something that truly enables me to consume the web in a manner that I can be personally satisfied with.
Wipr is also quite good for Safari!
For the in-video sponsors try sponsorblock.
Or FreeTube, an open source desktop YouTube client with sponsorblock built in.
LibreTube or Tubular on Android. Yattee with this guide on iOS.
❤️