Here’s an idea. Once you’ve already split the water molecules with electrolysis, you should throw those streams into separate mass spectrometers, but without the detector obviously. The idea is, that with ions flying in a magnetic field, their mass would determine where they land. Anything that isn’t the right kind of isotope, let alone right kind of atom, would be separated into the waste stream.
this post was submitted on 07 Sep 2024
445 points (100.0% liked)
xkcd
8839 readers
15 users here now
A community for a webcomic of romance, sarcasm, math, and language.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
What would be required for my wife to drink tap water.
Least convoluted factorio seablock recipe
This is how I felt trying to build a water purification system in Oxygen Not Included
The joke about adding well water back in again at the end is "correct". Reverse osmosis removes 100% of the solids from the water, but drinking water usually contains small quantities of solids - you can see a breakdown on the label of some bottled water. Completely pure water would leach all of the solids that have built up on the insides of water pipes over the decades, and leaches away the protective oxide layer from metal pipework, causing it to corrode surprisingly rapidly. It also tastes pretty shitty - kind of "dead". So a small amount of high-solids water is mixed back in after RO to bring the water back to normal levels.
All that other shit in the diagram? No. Purification and treatment takes place after the mixing step, it would be crazy not to.
Water taste is subjective. I absolutely hate the taste of high-mineral water and love pure water. RO or distilled water tastes absolutely amazing to me.
I assume you're some sort of serial killer. 😁
It is a joke image.
But also yes. Pure water tastes awful. I'm one of those "super" tasters and I used to work for a water filtration company. Lemme say... what people think they want and what they actually want are often two different things.
This is why we have remineralization filters I love my highly insane filtered water. Goes through 10 stages before finally hitting reverse osmosis just to extend the reverse osmosis filter life. But it has a alkaline remineralization as the last step so it tastes amazing
now you made me want to try it lol, where can I get 'dead' water? is distilled water the same thing?
Distilled is good enough for demonstration purposes.
Not quite, but very close
Yeah, I'm with you there - worked for twenty years in water treatment myself. Water before it's been chlorinated / chloraminated for supply? Makes the best cups of tea and coffee ever - you need to boil it, of course. RO water? Vile.
lol all that just to add well water back in at the end
Another article tag on explaixkcd that makes you go hmm 🤔😄
WATER. JUST PLAIN WATER. NOTHING DONE TO IT, JUST PLAIN WATER. POSSIBLY DRINKABLE. - Do NOT delete this tag too soon.
They always have fun with the "attribution" of that incomplete explanation tag for new comics 😄
Yeah I know, some are just better than others 😁
And none tickle me as much as the best {obvious thing} [Citation needed] ones 😄
Is this to scale?
I'm going to refer to lakes as "cosmic ray sterilization basins" from now on.