this post was submitted on 28 Aug 2024

1 points (100.0% liked)

Pop!_OS (Linux)

5105 readers

1 users here now

Pop!_OS is an operating system developed by System76 for STEM and creative professionals who use their computer as a tool to discover and create. Unleash your potential on secure, reliable open source software. Based on your exceptional curiosity, we sense you have a lot of it.

Unleash your potential

Whether this is your first experience with Linux, or your latest adventure, all are welcome to discuss and ask questions about Pop!_OS and COSMIC. Keep the discussions friendly though, and remember to assume good intentions whenever you reply. We're all here because we have a shared love for Linux and open source software.

Support us by buying System76 hardware for you or your company! Or by donating on the Pop!_OS website through the "Support Pop" button. Pop!_OS and COSMIC are fully funded by System76 hardware sales. All systems are assembled in the USA. With your support, we'll work to push the Linux desktop forward with COSMIC.

Links

Guides

Hardware

Recommended

Community Rules

Follow the Code of Conduct

All posts on pop_os must adhere to the Pop!_OS community Code of Conduct. https://github.com/pop-os/code-of-conduct

Be helpful

Posts to pop_os must be helpful. When responding to a user asking for help, do not provide tongue-in-cheek responses like "RTM" or links to LMGTFY. Linking to direct sources that answer the asker's question is fine, but it's advised to provide some explanation as to how you got to that source.

Critique should be constructive

We within the Pop!_OS community welcome helpful criticism or ideas on ways to improve. However, basic "It's bad" or other simple negative comments don't help anyone fix anything. When voicing a complaint about something, try to point out ways the complaint could be improved or worked around, so that we can make a better product for it.

This rule applies to both Pop!_OS and its projects as well as other products available from third-parties.

Don't post malicious "advice"

It can be funny to joke about malicious commands, however this is not the venue for it. Do not advise users to run commands which will lock up their systems, steal their data, or erase their drive. Examples of this include (but are not limited to) fork bombs, rm, etc.

Posts violating this rule will be removed, even if the post is clearly in jest. Repeated offences may lead to a ban. You may understand that the command isn't serious, but a new user might not.

No personal attacks

Posts making a personal attack on any user will not be tolerated.

No hate speech

Hate speech of any kind will not be tolerated. Any violations will be removed, and are grounds for a ban.

founded 1 year ago

MODERATORS

[email protected]

The problems and shortcomings of Cosmic (According to Hyprland Dev, Vaxry) (blog.vaxry.net)

submitted 1 month ago by [email protected] to c/[email protected]

2 comments fedilink hide all child comments

cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ndlug.org/post/1042162

My first impressions with cosmic were terrible to say the least. Amongst the sea of complete dealbreaker issues (horrible stutter and lag, inability to use 240hz, mouse sensitivity not working, etc) the general implementations atm are janky to say the least, tons of empty menus, wasted space, small annoying bugs.

I do realize it's an alpha, though, so I won't focus on the "small bugs" that can probably be fixed in 15 mins and will be fixed... in the future.

The current design language, IMO, is one of the worst I've seen in a while, but I don't wanna focus on this as it's all subjective, after all.

In this blogpost I want to focus on the broader ideology behind it, the direction and selling points.

...

Are we out of our minds? It's a barely functional alpha. All those quotes (and those are just a few) are at best running on "hopes and prayers" and not the actual experience. What foundation? Moving floating windows? MS Windows 3.0 had that. What potential? To... add more code? Just like to... anything at this stage?!

...

Cosmic is a desktop that, for now, to me, has no goal. Is not catchy. Has not much to offer. I don't know where System76 wants to take it, but if this doesn't change, it's not difficult for me to imagine a future where Cosmic ends up like Unity or Mir. Forgotten and barely used.

It's receiving a lot of overly-positive reviews based on hopes and prayers, with little to be based on reality, or what we have right now.

This, adding to the aggresive marketing, makes the developers already quite hostile to negative feedback.

Cosmic is, in my opinion, on a not-so-good path at the moment, despite what those news outlets might claim.

...

Even though this is a quite negative blogpost, if any of the developers at Cosmic are reading this: Stop riding on the great reviews. Accept criticism, because you know full well Cosmic is very rough at the moment. Criticism is the thing that will drive your code forward.

top 2 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old

[–] [email protected] 0 points 1 month ago

Are we out of our minds? It's a barely functional alpha.

No, you doorknob. People are excited, because it's a new DE from a company with a history of delivering a good user experience.

He says this isn't a competitor and he's not bothered by it, but this reads like somebody who's bothered by it and wants to shit on people's fun in response.

[–] [email protected] 0 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago)

I've tried to switch to lots of different desktop engines and distributions. Cosmic Alpha is incomplete, but I like it more as a starting place than alternatives. I've been using it for at least a week now.

I don't really like Gnome with Ubuntu. I've tried KDE with Fedora several times, but always break the theme somehow. The most sanest DE I've used is XFCE, which just seems too minimalist. PopOS with Cosmic at least starts off with drivers for a modern GPU, which I can't say for Fedora KDE which has always required some level of using the terminal to finish the install for me.

Cosmic is in rust, it seems easy to understand and follow for me. I was able to pick of current libs from it, and start hacking on stuff, which I can't say about other DE's because the build process for them usually seems very complex. I think Cosmic is also written specifically for Wayland, so it avoids lots of issues that all of the other current DE's face. (Which was a motivator in my decision to use it)

I like it. I think I'm going to continue using it. I'm just left wondering if the developers for it are using it as their primary DE, because I'm not 100% convinced.