this post was submitted on 12 Mar 2025
4 points (100.0% liked)
Witchcraft
198 readers
1 users here now
- cultural appropriation from exploited peoples will be moderated with gusto, but do not cry to the mod about a non-Italian getting into stregheria or a non-Scandinavian casting runes
- linking to an Etsy once or so is fine, but no spam
- please don't promote the arbitrary use of endangered species (e.g., palo santo that's Bulnesia sarmientoi) by modern practitioners
- some people's practice is religious, some people's practice is secular, let's all be respectful
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
What's her qualifications/background?
There's so much bullshit talked about the Mór-ríoġna that my first instinct is to be sceptical. How do we know this isn't another Robert Graves?
PS: your link says "Stephanie Woodfield (Brookfield, CT) has been a practicing Witch for over fourteen years and a Priestess for ten years. Her lifelong love of Irish mythology led to a close study of Celtic Witchcraft. A natural clairvoyant and empath, she has worked as a tarot card reader and is ordained as a minister with the Universal Life Church."
I'm not NECESSARILY against yanks studying our paganism (e.g. Erynn Rowan Laurie writes very competently and respectfully on it), but this woman doesn't seem to have any history/linguistic/anthro qualifications either (she'd've said it in her author bio if she did)
Anyway I found it on Annas-Archive, I'll have a look and give you my thoughts after the workday if I get time. Bad first impressions.
PPS: Flicked to the 'pronunciation guide' at the back and there's a few mistakes but it's not as bad as I feared.
Cailleach (ky-lee-ACK)
– why is the C velarised if it's broad??Fir Bolg (FEER-bolg)
– at least transliterate itFEER-bulg
....Morrigan (MORE-ee-gan)
– at least she got the first vowel correct (yanks on youtube don't) but she hasn't softened the G....Ogham (OH-gum or OH-um)
– it's clear she doesn't speak the languageThis is a good, detailed take. She's not a scholar, just a witch doing her best. And this is more of an account of one person's personal practice than a detailed, academic historical text. Still, I think she does a better job than most of what's out there. As always (for anyone else out there following this thread) read with a grain of salt. Or a barrel of salt.
If you have good book recommendations, I think I speak for everyone lurking when I say please post them.
Here are some primary sources about her:
https://www.maryjones.us/ctexts/regamna.html
http://www.maryjones.us/ctexts/1maghtured.html
http://www.maryjones.us/ctexts/2maghtured.html
Book: https://www.morrigan.academy/book